Forget-a-Bout Tony
I have attended several weddings, business functions, and private dinners at the Carltun. The professional service and exceptionally polite staff is exceeded only by the outstanding cuisine. I, like many other Long Islanders, cherish this "DIAMOND-IN-THE-ROUGH" restaurant, and shall continue to be a regular patron (we have reservations this week!). As for Tony's opinion above, we all have been to weddings with unkind guests, whose embaressingly loud, obnoxiously-outspoken behaviour becomes an uncomfortable experience to be endured by those unfortunate enough to be near him. (Pray for him, and ignore his low self-esteem outbursts). This is certainly a vintage establishment, a great place to impress out of town guests (they will rave about your great dining choice).
Food: 10
Service: 10
Ambiance: 10
Overall: 8
- NUMC

Awesome Venue
I attended a wedding there this month and it was excellent. The venue is gorgeous, the food fabulous and the staff highly professional!
Food: 10
Service: 10
Ambiance: 10
Overall: 10

I absolutely loved the inviting atmosphere, the elegance of the hall, and the accomadating staff. Overall it was a wonderful experience and not your typical catering hall!
Food: 10
Service: 10
Ambiance: 10
Overall: 8
-

Outstanding Wedding
I just attended a wedding at the Carltun, Eisenhower Park. on September 8th. It is by far the best wedding I have ever attended. The food and service was outstanding. People were incredibly helpful. It was just like eating in a fourstar restaurant. I heard many wonderful comments from the other guests at the wedding.
Recommended: baby lamb chops, tuna steak and swordfish steak appetizers, raspberry vinaigrette salad, chilean sea bass, filet mignon
Food: 10
Service: 10
Ambiance: 10
Overall: 10

Rudeness of restaurant staff
I was a guest in a wedding reception at the Carltun, Eisenhower Park. I regret to complain that the rudeness of the staff overshadowed the elegance of the place. "The hands of your waitress is already in front of my face to take my drinking glass which was still in my mouth". The removal of plates was deliberately made in a hurry without any politeness shown, and the waiters and waitresses at table #12 were with unfriendly looks. What characters!!
Food: 4
Service: 2
Ambiance: 8
Overall: 4