Over the years, we've eaten at 231 Ellsworth on numerous occasions, sometimes for special events, but just as many times, if not more, simply because it's good. Having dined there over the last couple of decades, we are especially happy with the offerings of the current chef, Tim Hilt. He and his kitchen bring fresh, seasonally updated versions of classics with inventive twists and the presentation is at once elegant and whimsical. Most importantly, though, is that the food is delicious. We never worry about whether we should order seafood on certain days of the week. Without exception, everything they serve is fresh. To that end, I was surprised at a previous post that they found the ahi to be disappointing. Our experience was the polar opposite. We found it to extraordinarily fresh and flavorful, exquisite really,--not always our experience when we've dined elsewhere. I would encourage them to give the restaurant another try. We wouldn't hesitate to highly recommend this restaurant.

Amazing Fine Dinning Experience
I have been to 231 Ellsworth many times, and I have to say that it is my favorite restaurant for fine dinning. Do yourself a treat and order the five course tasting menu with the wine paring. You will not find a better experience anywhere! If one of the items is not really what you want, just ask and they will gladly change it. (My wife won’t eat wild) I have not tried the Vegetarian option, but I just might next time. The wine paring are perfect too. Take a few hours to really enjoy it and treat it as an adventure. You will thank me…..
Recommended: Roasted baby beet salad with baked goat cheese
Food: 10
Service: 10
Ambiance: 10
Overall: 10

Yikes! Stay away!
Let's start with the meals... I had the NY steak that was less than promised in portion. And NOT cooked the way I liked it. When I asked nicely to have a few more minutes on the grill-the server did not return my meal for 15 minutes! To boot, it was lukewarm in the middle. Did they microwave it?? I guess they don't like people suggesting how they want something. Not to mention our "service" diminished after that. My wife asked twice for coffee and her main course of bass (I think) tasted as bland as could be. All this for $75! Sorry folks but fast food would be a way better option.
Recommended: Sorry-None!
Food: 2
Service: 4
Ambiance: 6
Overall: 2
- San Mateo